P is for Permaculture … and Plotting




Permaculture is a topic I have been reading about a lot over the last couple of years. I got to see some of its principles in action in a few places across England, including the Garth Hillside Community Garden in Wales (and to a lesser degree, the first Helpx place I went to in Scotland). It is basically a theory of agriculture marrying traditional practices — generally the pre-twentieth-century attitudes and practices — with modern science. It seeks to create a sustainable agriculture — permanent agriculture — by imitating natural processes and including human beings in the ecosystems. It is in many ways a garden agriculture, rather than a farming one. The idea is to have more food with less work, to share with the wild world and other people, to create beauty and bounty. It embraces ideas of stewardship, of responsibility, of reclaiming the land.Ferns

I like that it is sensible: it looks to what we can learn from old ways, and what we have learned through the wide-ranging experiments in chemistry that was the twentieth century, and what was trying to be gained in the back-to-the-land movements of the 6os and 70s, and what they were missing. Permaculture values deep thought and intelligent design over having to fix mistakes that could have been avoided. The goal is to have the waste products of one part of the system fulfill the necessary requirements of another part, rather than being waste — or needing artificial inputs.

companion planting

An example I have come across recently is what’s called aquaponics. This is a combination of aquaculture and hydroponics that theoretically, at least, should avoid the major problems of each by putting them together. One problem with farming fish is the sheer quantity of waste that fish make, and the exacerbation of the unhealthiness formed by keeping fish in a contained area. One problem with hydroponics (the growing of plants, usually vegetables, in a nutrient-rich solution rather than in the soil, obviously an attractive option for those of us in northern climates who still like fresh vegetables during the winter) is that the nutrient-rich solution used is full of chemical nutrients, which can build up to toxic levels, need often to replaced (thus using a lot of water), and require a lot of energy to create in the first place.

The aquaponics solution, according to its promoters, is to put these things together. The nutrient solution is formed by the water from the fish tank, pumped through the growing medium of the growing beds, broken down by the right combination of bacteria and compost worms. You still need the external input of fish food (though you could grow some of that, too), electricity for the pump, and lights for the plants through the winter, but the problem of the fish waste on the one hand and the chemical solution on the other are fixed through the combination of elements and smart design.

Garth Hillside

I should note that I have not tried this, but I do think it’s a very cool idea and intend to once I have the resources and space. (Fish are like worm compost bins or mushroom logs, not something I want in the same room I sleep in, even if they’re not actually going to do anything to me; they just wig me out a little. Dogs, certainly. Cats, no problem except that the kitty litter isn’t going anywhere near my bed, either…) I use it as an example of permaculture’s principle of finding the best use of waste — so it is no longer waste, but compost, water, energy, food. (William Morris’ principle in action! Manure becomes beautiful when it is useful?)

What, you may ask, has this to do with plotting? Well — quite a lot, I think.

Cold frames

You see, another principle of permaculture is the idea that things should have multiple functions — of which beauty or pleasure can definitely be one — and that each function should be served by multiple things, if possible, for resiliency, redundancy in case of any one part failing, and general strength of the overall system. This to me is what one strives for in writing, as well. Each scene — ideally each paragraph, maybe even each sentence — should fulfill multiple functions: reveal character, describe setting, reinforce (or introduce) the theme, drive the plot forward, be lovely, oh, there are all sorts of things. The strongest stories are ones where all that comes together at once; they are the ones that reward deep study, that are utterly satisfying on many levels.


This is why I love the Divine Comedy or Lois McMaster Bujold’s The Curse of Chalion (very, very different as those works are): they speak forth on many levels at the same time. You don’t need to be paying attention at each level, because the author was, and has shaped the story. I didn’t really like Herman Hesse’s Siddartha when I read it except for one brilliant realisation that has always stayed with me, that the whole book is found in the first line. The meaning of that line is not to be known until the story has unfolded out of it … but there it is.DSCF7253

This takes a combination of planning and inspiration and serendipity, I think; and all that is in the forming of a garden, too. Like the plants that go one way instead of another, characters take on a life of their own, the plot suddenly twists, you realise that what you thought was so is in fact something else entirely. It’s a strange feeling, the reciprocity involved in writing — as author you are both creator and somehow collaborator. In gardening it’s a lot clearer that this is so, and we have a name for the collaborator, Nature. But in both, I think, the beauty comes from the struggle to make depth and resonance out of recalcitrant parts and pieces that each have their several beauties. Combine them one way and one has a Japanese garden speaking koans; combine them another way and one has an English cottage garden speaking to us of Shakespeare and Austen.

I think that’s pretty cool.



4 thoughts on “P is for Permaculture … and Plotting

  1. Victoria, you are an amazing young woman and I am constantly being astonished and intrigued by your thought processes. Where you find the time and the energy to do your thought provoking writing, I shall never know!!! I am enjoying my reading experiences with your writing. Thank you for sharing.


  2. I have only started learning about permaculture but the principles really speak to me. Imagine if the idea really took hold: like if public parks and those areas along roadways were designed as sustainable food forests? Charles Mann suggests in his amazing book 1491 that the Amazon river basin is basically the leftover from just such a vision: that it was a human created garden that has lasted for centuries.


  3. It is pretty neat, isn’t it? I think what I like about it is that it’s so sensible, and fits all sorts of different philosophies. There’s a group of people turning empty fields in Charlottetown, Prince Edward Island, into a community garden and food forest — and that’s a place where conventional agriculture (potatoes) is the central industry.

    I’ll have to look at 1491. I feel that I’ve heard some reference to the Amazon basin being like that, but I’m not sure where … possibly in Monty Don’s “Around the World in 80 Gardens”? (He visits some of the floating gardens of the Amazon.) Hmm. There’s a book about pre-European-contact Australia, “The Greatest Estate on Earth,” by Bill Gammage, that talks about Australia in similar terms. One of the cool things about the system as he describes it there is that the idea is plenty with minimal work to permit time for culture — which I think we can get behind!


  4. I’d never heard the term permaculture before, so once again I learn something from A to Z blog hopping. I love how you equate permaculture and plotting because it really does make sense. Writing is not just throwing words on the page, it’s planning from large plot ideas to small details of how a sentence makes you feel. And while I’m not a gardener, I’ve seen enough of what family members with green thumbs do to know it takes planning, too.

    Hope you’re having fun with the A to Z challenge,


Join the Conversation

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s